KELLY CLARKSON VS. MARIAH CAREY

[sooks]

i like kelly clarkson all her songs are GOOD!!! :lmao: :loool: :w000t:

my favorite songs from her are "because of you" and "behind these hazel eyes"

 

[iluvnumandoil]

i dont think u could put mariah to compare with all these young pop star.. she in a league of her own....she would be like celine dion or whitney houston, her music has been here for more than a decade.
Dont get me wrong but these r all beautiful ladies here...but yeah i voted for mariah

 

[Hiatus]

eh I go for Mariah and Christina.. like iluvnumandoil said... they are different still these two are like woahhh they can both nail all the singers listed above with their voice

 

[T3rRi]

I like Christina Aguilera.

 

[sooks]

i use to like mariah's voice.. but now.. her voice seems so annoying to me!!! she's so squeky. i think christina sings way better. i forgot to put sarah McClaghan..

 

[iluvnumandoil]

i use to like mariah's voice.. but now.. her voice seems so annoying to me!!! she's so squeky. i think christina sings way better. i forgot to put sarah McClaghan..

[post="67606"][/post]​

sarah who?

 

[karenyang]

my vote goes to Mariah.....

 

[Rakniran]

Jessica Simpson I would vote for since Mariah Carey is the Queen already.She shouldnt even be on the list with those younger girls.They are new comer and Mariah Carey have been there forever..

 

[Bou]

i vote for christin aguilera one of my fav singers!

 

[Thookatha]

"me and mariah, go back like babies and pacifi-yahs"!

 

[pii-nky]

i voted kelly clarkson. i would of voted for mariah carey, but after what i saw her do on the new years celebration all posing like a re-nob! but i still love her =)

 

[Kina]

mariah has turned to be a classic...she can't be compared to those girls because they're just newly bloomed butterflies. i love mariah still, ever since way back when she was new.

the other girls sing pretty well in their own music category, rock or pop or r&b.

since im more of a rocker with a twist of r&b, i went with Kelly

 

[KawaiiTennyo]

mariah carey is a "diva" with the top singers.. i think christina aguilera could be one of the "divas" she got awesome pipe! compared to the rest of them..

 

[Kelly]

wow my two fav. are at a tie now ahha...tho i voted for kelly b/c i like her alot more and i saw how she got famous ahha! Mariah i love her music too ehhe! especially...actually i'm in love with "we belong together"-it reminds me of someone ehhe!

 

[amikaX]

i unno, i would vote for any of them, jus not britney and ashlee... but i jus chose jessica :sweat:

 

[marduk]

Britney Spears!!! Oh baby oh baby one more time! Sometimes I just drive myself crazy!

I just voted for her. *Sigh*.

I remember when her first video came out. She was so hawt! Now she's a mom...and she's not even a MILF. She needs to stop smoking.

But she's still the coolest.

 

[bugsy]

hey! Where's Miss Alicia Keys???!!!! I lovers her!! She needs to be up there too! LOL>

I like all the above, either still do or at one point in my life...^_^...but..pertaining to the question...from the list...i would pick Kelly Clarkson, although all of them have their own good qualities. Second would be Avril Lavigne. Just because Im more of a punker than a pop person.

 

[AznGirlTha]

mariah all the way! i love all her songs! she's a really good singer and she performs her best everytime she perform.

 

[Oil]

I love Mariah Carey, love her songs and her voice; she is simply one of the best singers in r&b, beside Whitney Houston

 

[1-lUv3-y0u]

I like alot of those singers but I'd choose Mariah Carey I mean because fore someone like her she still have such a nice voice and it's amazing she can heck scrram and omg i just lover all her songs well at least almost haha but yeah she's one of my favorite Amrican celebirty singers