❤️[CH3] My Love From the Stars (Broadcast Thai Television) : Nadech Kugimiya / Matt Peranee
- Thread starter dancy
- Start date
I think Nadech is the best A-list actor at Ch3 out of the rest of the male A-listers. He still has more potential to grow though which is a good thing. However I don’t think he’s the best actor in all of Thailand. I think there’s lots of guys who far surpass him in terms of acting such as Alex Rendell and Got. Those dudes are pure talent but unfortunately I think both of them are not really super invested in the acting life lately. That’s just my personal opinion though.
ArabellaRose
sarNie Hatchling
Everyone has potential to grow Including the best. Nadech has not tackled any really unusual role to really gauge the extent of his ability. But from all the roles that he took, they all come across as natural, Also, I think it’s harder to win awards when your role is ordinary person. Example military, farmer etc. ( roles without much screaming and cryin) as opposed if you play someone with disability or complex character. Because it’s hard to make the characters stand out and be noticed for awards. The best thing one can do when playing ordinary roles is to be as natural as possible which is what he did, if he can win awards playing ordinary people, that would mean he did a great job. And so I think he can most definitely can win playing unusual character.
These actors you’ve mentioned, I saw one of them (A. Rendell) and I thought he just act ok,. i don’t know how many awards they received. Because again personal opinions would vary from person to person, Each have their own idea of who is excellent. You are entitled to yours . The entertainment industry has their own professional critics to judge these performances.
But I disagree that many surpasses his acting.I think Nadech is one of the few best.. True it’s my personal opinion. But the awards, also speaks for itself.
I don’t really see awards as much of an indicator of talent in Thailand. I’m not saying that Nadech is not talented because he definitely is it’s just that he gets most of the awards cause he’s the most popular in his category. Rarely do awards go to people who actually deserve them in Thailand. A lot of the time they just give it to the person who attends the event in Asian award shows or to the one who is most popular. You are entitled to your opinion though and I’m not trying to change it, I’m just sharing mine
To me, Tor Thanapob is a better actor than Nadech. He has more of a natural emotional stage presence and can easily convey his emotions through his eyes. And there are scenes that Tor can be so subtle but yet it's somehow became very impressive and unforgettable. Maybe because in HJS he comes across more like a Chinese ML than an actor in a lakorn.
Nadech is a good actor but I don't think he's a prolific one. Maybe in his movie koo Kum didn't leave a good impression on me. The way he took on Kobori was a bit confusing. He made kobori looks like a slow man. Anyway, maybe my comparison isn't fair but watching other actors in different countries made me realize how limited Thai actors are. I am watching Vuslat (Turkish drama) and the actor Kadir Dogulu is probably one of the best actor I have seen that can let his eyes do all the talking for him. The way he can make you nervous or on edge by his eyes movements alone. I find it so memorizing when an actor acts with their eyes and tell a story without so much a word, that's true talent. I wished more thai actors can get to that level.
Nadech is a good actor but I don't think he's a prolific one. Maybe in his movie koo Kum didn't leave a good impression on me. The way he took on Kobori was a bit confusing. He made kobori looks like a slow man. Anyway, maybe my comparison isn't fair but watching other actors in different countries made me realize how limited Thai actors are. I am watching Vuslat (Turkish drama) and the actor Kadir Dogulu is probably one of the best actor I have seen that can let his eyes do all the talking for him. The way he can make you nervous or on edge by his eyes movements alone. I find it so memorizing when an actor acts with their eyes and tell a story without so much a word, that's true talent. I wished more thai actors can get to that level.
Last edited:
Ntsuab-Ci
In love with Phet & Mookda <3
OMG, I loved that drama when it was airing... season 1? Or the first half before the break. Yes, the male lead is pretty good. He definitely made me nervous when he was first introduced and then he became all soft and cute towards female lead, hehe.
Lakorns are so boring and draggy. And I hate slap-kiss, which seems to be Thai audience’s favourite genre. I respect people’s taste but never understand why someone would want to watch a show where other women being tortured/mistreated/raped by their supposedly fated ones. So I only watch light hearted lakorns and mostly for the eye candies. If I want good acting and plots, I will watch American TV series or Hollywood movies.
Because I haven’t seen any lakorn actors that can impress me yet. On the other hands, I watch a few movies by GHD and I think the acting is quite natural.
Talking about awards, I agree that one should not use that to measure how good an actor is. Nadech did get a lots of awards, however I think lots of them are in the popular categories. Tbh, I was shocked at how low cost, cheap looking and unorganised some award shows in Thailand were. Some of them look like a show at a village fair.
I would like to see Nadech in movies more. Lakorns are so boring and all the kissing scenes are so stiff because for CH3, it would look inappropriate if the women are more active in those scenes? Jeez. Look at Matt, she’s a good actress but still act shy when it comes to kissing. It’s part of the reason why you see no sparks between them.
Because I haven’t seen any lakorn actors that can impress me yet. On the other hands, I watch a few movies by GHD and I think the acting is quite natural.
Talking about awards, I agree that one should not use that to measure how good an actor is. Nadech did get a lots of awards, however I think lots of them are in the popular categories. Tbh, I was shocked at how low cost, cheap looking and unorganised some award shows in Thailand were. Some of them look like a show at a village fair.
I would like to see Nadech in movies more. Lakorns are so boring and all the kissing scenes are so stiff because for CH3, it would look inappropriate if the women are more active in those scenes? Jeez. Look at Matt, she’s a good actress but still act shy when it comes to kissing. It’s part of the reason why you see no sparks between them.
You need to watch season 2 episode 24 (the last part of the episode). My goodness, Kadir made me so uncomfortable the way he sits there and stare at Feride. I mean, I have seen a ML stared intensely at the FL but not to the level of Kadir though. He almost made me squirm in my seat. He has such impressionable eyes. I can watch his scenes and focused just on his eyes...I have watched some of his old dramas didn't quite think his acting stood out but in Vuslat he definitely made Aziz a character to remember. His acting has polished and more mature.
Ntsuab-Ci
In love with Phet & Mookda <3
I was going to start! Like I clicked on the episode and everything, but then I heard/saw that he lost his memories or something? & I was like ugh, nope. I really don't like plots like that. But is that true? Lol. I never confirmed.
No, he didn't lose his memories. He fake it to revenge the crazies around him lol. I mean, he remembers everyone except Feride. His intention was to protect her by not remembering her but he went about it the wrong way. I don't think it went well for him though cause his feelings are written all over his eyes. Anyhow, episode 24 is when she found out that he lied to her and it's a very good scene between Aziz and Feride. I'm glad they didn't drag it out that long...cause their scenes are so short to begin with and him trying to fake it out wasn't going to cut it hahaha.
Waffle
❤ BTS ❤
I was looking for this comment. Tor is literally so good at acting, i even watched the very beginning of LLSR after finding out he was in there and you can see the difference between his acting and Nadech’s. I use to think Nadech was so good until I started to watch other lakorns/dramas
Ntsuab-Ci
In love with Phet & Mookda <3
I hate that he doesn't remember her, ugh. But I'm glad to hear that it's short lived! Okay! You sold me, haha. I'll go watch it.
He remembers her, he just act like he doesn't. Remember people are out to get him and if he pretends he doesn't know Feride she'll be safe...
There is one scene in HJS that made me realize how good of an actor Tor is, that is the scene when Minta was sleeping on the small couch with her forehead bandaged up. That scene requires some restrained on his acting but at the same time make it believable where the sight of her hurt impacted him in such a way. The way his voice dropped, the fragile and emotions registering in his eyes...in that scene he was brilliant. He displayed such deep emotions in them wounded eyes. And I don't think Nadech is strong enough to carry that scene the way Tor could.
ArabellaRose
sarNie Hatchling
Hahaha I guess this really shows you the interest for MLFAS remake, I thought for awhile I was at a different forum. No one is even interested to talk about it, LOL
. No one is even interested to talk about it, LOL
Ntsuab-Ci
In love with Phet & Mookda <3
Oohhh! Okay. Then I can totally watch it. It'll just hurt me for a while until she realizes lol
