❤️[CH3] My Love From the Stars (Broadcast Thai Television) : Nadech Kugimiya / Matt Peranee

ArabellaRose

sarNie Hatchling
I can’t help but feel somwhat concern for Nadech. :confused12:If they copy all of them. Especially The red carpet Kiss . I Hope it doesn’t become controversial. Cause this remake is so not worth it for his career. Perhaps he got paid a lot. But all things considered with the scandal and quality of this remake.. I just think he wasted a full 1 year shooting this. Then for the first time kissing someone other than yaya and not just one kiss but many real kisses. The korean version wasn’t shy when it comes to kisses. I don’t think Koreans do any fake one.lol. When I heard they want to film it a certain way. I thought Nadech is going to have to do some real serious kissing.. and more than he ever had in any of his lakorns as this drama is known for many iconic kisses.:risas3:. I know he has many real fans. But I’m sure there are also who would be those disappointed, Of all the actresses he has to kiss. It could have been mew or Kim or taew. But, It’s someone involved in scandal whom many people don’t like ..lol.. I wonder what the reaction of those people would be to Nadech kissing Matt. LOL. Right away bcsuse the remake went up by .2 there already many people promoting the kisses :risas3: Like for coming episodes that can be what they show as a preview.lol..I think there are that many kisses if I’m not mistake from the original.... LoL..This might end up to be known as one of those who become popular bcsuse of skinship instead of The quality of remake , the story and the acting,.. it would not be good for the actors,:facepalm:
 
Last edited:

spanky

sarNie OldFart
Ananda...adapt/remake k series and make it his own at least....

He add more sweet scenes and make them less rigid
 

byebye

sarNie OldFart
I can’t help but feel somwhat concern for Nadech. :confused12:If they copy all of them. Especially The red carpet Kiss . I Hope it doesn’t become controversial. Cause this remake is so not worth it for his career. Perhaps he got paid a lot. But all things considered with the scandal and quality of this remake.. I just think he wasted a full 1 year shooting this. Then for the first time kissing someone other than yaya and not just one kiss but many real kisses. The korean version wasn’t shy when it comes to kisses. I don’t think Koreans do any fake one.lol. When I heard they want to film it a certain way. I thought Nadech is going to have to do some real serious kissing.. and more than he ever had in any of his lakorns as this drama is known for many iconic kisses.:risas3:. I know he has many real fans. But I’m sure there are also who would be those disappointed, Of all the actresses he has to kiss. It could have been mew or Kim or taew. But, It’s someone involved in scandal whom many people don’t like ..lol.. I wonder what the reaction of those people would be to Nadech kissing Matt. LOL. Right away bcsuse the remake went up by .2 there already many people promoting the kisses :risas3: Like for coming episodes that can be what they show as a preview.lol..I think there are that many kisses if I’m not mistake from the original.... LoL..This might end up to be known as one of those who become popular bcsuse of skinship instead of The quality of remake , the story and the acting,.. it would not be good for the actors,:facepalm:
Bless their little hearts if all they have is being mad or disappointed that an actor is doing his job. That's a cushion life.

Nadech will be fine going forward with or without this remake. I mean, they hand picked him from the beginning. Being an actor sometimes you have to kiss a frog rather than the princess lol. But as a professional they have to put on a happy face and take one for the team hahaha.

And this lakorn isn't going to put a dent on his popularity let alone his career. He's so darn popular he probably got some young girls following his IG even if he turns 80 lol. Now, Matt on the other hand...that's another whole universe of a story :)
 

tinav

sarNie Egg
Matt looks a lot older than Nadech
And I think Taew or Mew would be better playing off this cute clumsy dumb role.
Matt has evil face to be playing a dumb innocent role
 

byebye

sarNie OldFart
Matt looks a lot older than Nadech
And I think Taew or Mew would be better playing off this cute clumsy dumb role.
Matt has evil face to be playing a dumb innocent role
[/QUOTE]

It depends on how they style her. At the hospital in the earlier episode with less makeup she actually looks the same age as Na and a degree younger. With cake make up she looks older but not by much. That's why this older woman and younger man thing didn't work for me. Taew and Mew is a no-no regardless. If they want to make it obvious it has to be the likes of Araya and Bee N.
 

spanky

sarNie OldFart
Matt looks a lot older than Nadech
And I think Taew or Mew would be better playing off this cute clumsy dumb role.
Matt has evil face to be playing a dumb innocent role

Isn't the nk suppose to be older....

I kind of watch the k version....she is also older....I was soo bored lol
 

ArabellaRose

sarNie Hatchling
:)
Matt looks a lot older than Nadech
And I think Taew or Mew would be better playing off this cute clumsy dumb role.
Matt has evil face to be playing a dumb innocent role
I really don't know about looking evil. LOL.. But maybe it's her acting or maybe its her scandal. I just do not like looking at her. :risas3:. miles and miles away from JJH, image wise. At this point the age thing isn't a major factor. They should have cast someone who's easy to look at.:)
 

ArabellaRose

sarNie Hatchling
Bless their little hearts if all they have is being mad or disappointed that an actor is doing his job. That's a cushion life.

Nadech will be fine going forward with or without this remake. I mean, they hand picked him from the beginning. Being an actor sometimes you have to kiss a frog rather than the princess lol. But as a professional they have to put on a happy face and take one for the team hahaha.

And this lakorn isn't going to put a dent on his popularity let alone his career. He's so darn popular he probably got some young girls following his IG even if he turns 80 lol. Now, Matt on the other hand...that's another whole universe of a story :)
You're right about his popularity, I suppose. :)However I was thinking more about the future offers he gets. In accepting this drama, I wonder if he is now in danger of getting bad roles ( as if they can't do any better with most of his past roles, lol. I think hes just a good actor that was able to portray the roles well. ) I meant what if he now gets more offered of lakorns focused on skinship as opposed to challenging roles and good quality dramas? I really am hoping not and trying to think positive.
:) but that's what I wondering about. I don't know how it is in Thailand. But in other countries like USA one can get typecasted in something.
 

byebye

sarNie OldFart
You're right about his popularity, I suppose. :)However I was thinking more about the future offers he gets. In accepting this drama, I wonder if he is now in danger of getting bad roles ( as if they can't do any better with most of his past roles, lol. I think hes just a good actor that was able to portray the roles well. ) I meant what if he now gets more offered of lakorns focused on skinship as opposed to challenging roles and good quality dramas? I really am hoping not and trying to think positive.
:) but that's what I wondering about. I don't know how it is in Thailand. But in other countries like USA one can get typecasted in something.
The only typecast Nadech is having is with Yaya hahhaha. He has the luxury of picking projects so I wouldn't worry too much about him in the future. He's set at channel 3...I mean he's like royalty there so he's not going to be short on lakorns. He has plenty of time to be in more lakorns probably more mature roles as he gets older. There's nothing wrong about a lakorn with skinship if done right. I would watch lakorn with plenty of that vs one where the leads would be apart episodes at a time. But the catch is, chemistry has to be there. I mean, lakorn with lots of touching isn't worth watching if the couples come across like watching dry paint. And if that's the case give me a good plot and the leads can be separated for 10 episodes and I'm Ok lol
 

ArabellaRose

sarNie Hatchling
The only typecast Nadech is having is with Yaya hahhaha. He has the luxury of picking projects so I wouldn't worry too much about him in the future. He's set at channel 3...I mean he's like royalty there so he's not going to be short on lakorns. He has plenty of time to be in more lakorns probably more mature roles as he gets older. There's nothing wrong about a lakorn with skinship if done right. I would watch lakorn with plenty of that vs one where the leads would be apart episodes at a time. But the catch is, chemistry has to be there. I mean, lakorn with lots of touching isn't worth watching if the couples come across like watching dry paint. And if that's the case give me a good plot and the leads can be separated for 10 episodes and I'm Ok lol
Actually I’m talking more of being typecast like only skinship and showing his body without any plot or good story. LoL. I don’t think he would accept that role haha.l I wonder what roles he turned down. Just curious, . Him pairing up with yaya is fine as long as the role is challenging/ interesting.. I don’t think they pair up all the time. Maybe frequently....lol...it’s different from all the time,.LOL Hey in other countries love teams are hardly paired up with others they’re basically stuck with each other,,. I mean in movies and dramas etc, LOL

If there is any typecast for Nadech its a police/military role. :risas3:Like seriously, he was involved in land/ farm stuffs like 3 times then police/military like I don’t know so many times lol.. Even in this new lakorn he’s still military...only in a different era.:risas3: I do like NY. But I think they want to work with each other so much that when an offer comes for them to work together they accept it right away I’m sure there would probably be more than 1 offer, and they can choose which lakorns are really good. But perhaps they take the very 1st offer. So the others still thinking of offering for them never got a chance., As for the military typecast, .these people who offers the roles don’t they care that Nadech played it so many times? :confused12: Or perhaps that’s why They offer it to him because now he’s like an expert military actor. LoL. Although if I’m him, I’ll get exhausted thinking of playing each military role differently becsuse it needs to be different from others. I suppose the character itself makes it different -like the personality of the character,

Anyways, as for skinship, I don’t think a drama especially an outstanding one needs a lot of it. If It’s an outstanding lakorn, even barely there skinship people wouldnt mind, As long as it is outstanding In every level. In a great lakorn if there is skinship it should just be an added extra not the main attraction like what would seem To happen in this remake,lol. Because it has nothing else .No chemistry, bad editing, many bad actors, lol. Nadech is probably the only one doing well actingwise.. But we don’t even know how a real alien acts like,,lol.
 
Last edited:

its_ann

sarNie Hatchling
Interesting to read all the feedback on this lakorn. I tried watching the first episode but I couldn’t get into it. I’ll probably watch it when it’s finished airing. This may be off topic, but does anyone know if Nadech have any other lakorn lined up other than the one with Yaya?
 

sksen19

sarNie Egg
I never find Nadech and Yaya have any chemistry on screen but off screen they do have chemistry. Nadech is pretty good in acting although he's not great. I like that he chose to act with other actresses and not just paired up with Yaya (they have whole life time together off screen). Kissing on screen is part of the job so I see nothing wrong with it. I am sure he gets paid alot.
 

ArabellaRose

sarNie Hatchling
I never find Nadech and Yaya have any chemistry on screen but off screen they do have chemistry. Nadech is pretty good in acting although he's not great. I like that he chose to act with other actresses and not just paired up with Yaya (they have whole life time together off screen). Kissing on screen is part of the job so I see nothing wrong with it. I am sure he gets paid alot.
Hm. I think they have chemistry on and off. I don’t think they will win many couple awards and they also have many fans If they don’t have chemistry. They just needEd to choose the best lakorn to do. Like Game Rai Game Ruk .Becsuse theyve been accepting Work it seem just to work with each other. This one theyre doing now i think is a good one. Both does work with others. But they decide that they want to work with each other.

I think Nadech is one of the best actor in thailand if not the best. Thats is the reason why he has the most awards in the history of Thailand. He has about 170.. The 2nd person with the most award is a lot older and didnt even reach 90 awards.
 
Last edited:

ArabellaRose

sarNie Hatchling
I wouldn’t put awards received in Thailand as benchmark of being a best actor. They throw out awards likes it’s candy. Who show up gets an award.
? Arent those best actor/actress awards decided by several people in the industry and not by just one person ? If the awards aren’t the benchmark, what is the benchmark?Ratings by fans would be biased. So it can’t be the benchmark. And Ratings or popularity of a drama can’t single out a performers ability of being excellent or not .Because many things can contribute to a drama ratings Such as good storyline and characters . Doesn’t mean their actors are really good..so it can’t be the benchmark as well.,.
Isn’t it for the purpose of judging the individual performance of an actor or actress that’s why they have those award show judged by people in the industry? I mean IF it’s fair to say for example that an actor is a good actor even though he didn’t get an award. I think it would be more unfair to say that an actor who got awards as many, as 170 is not one of the best actors around. Because awards that many can’t be all unjustified.

i also have a feeling. It’s not who shows up that gets an award. I think they told them ahead who gets the award that’s why they show up. Therefore giving the impression to viewers that you only need to show up, to win,.
 
Last edited:

Som123

sarNie Egg
not all awards are reliable but Nadech is undeniably a good actor. I bet most people in the industry will agree with me lols. The others actors in CH3 are just .....
 
Top