❤️[CH3] My Love From the Stars (Broadcast Thai Television) : Nadech Kugimiya / Matt Peranee

Koy123

sarNie OldFart
They shouldn’t try to remake a slow Kdrama in the first place. Korean culture and value are different than Thais that they just can’t relate.
 

poobae91

sarNie Adult
Honestly, I was never fond of this story line. Even the Korean version was boring for me; I tried to pick it up 3 times, and out of curiosity due to this lakorn, I finally was able to went further past where I last stopped haha.
 

ArabellaRose

sarNie Hatchling
What they did is almost like self sabotage. LOL.

Ok technically They did many wrong things. That alone would possibly have made the drama rating go down to maybe 4 or 3

Then They had the scandal.. That turned off people in general who arent even fan of either one. So lets say it went down further to 3 to 2.5

That leaves the fans of Nadech and Matt to support the drama. But matt dont have much fans and I think from those many are disappointed either with Matt or the remake itslef. So they didnt watch.it . Now we're left with Nadechs fans. Most are NY fans But I think many of them(NY fans) though they want to support Nadech are also turned off by the scandal and the remake.. then they also would have to watch nadech kiss another actress for real. And it isnt just 1 or 2 or 3 or4 barely touch lips. The love scenes are more than any lovescenes NY had done in any lakorns..So its on their own discretion and rights if they want to watch it since they are NY fans not MatT/Nadech fans. If i were to guess i dont think many of them would watch it.

So we're left withNadech"s fans....well... i think many of them might endure the "bad remake" But i think most of them don't like matt either because of the scandal.

I really think The scandal cut a major chunk of the audience. And the other avenues that might have helped like a really good remake isnt there. Nadechs powerhouse are his fans and also NY fans But in this case becauae of many love scenes it would be more on his solo fans, unfortunately many of them didnt lkke either matt scandal or the remake enough to watch
Although if theyre real fans they can endure the bad remake as long as they see nadech there.. but not if they really cant stand matt. So i really think if Nadechs solo fans dont watch its really the scandal issue.

Anyway, im just trying to guess a breakdown of why it went all the way down to 1.8/1,6
 
Last edited:

pikachu

sarNie Egg
I don’t think Matts the reason this is a flop. I think her scandal and the fallout from it is the cherry on top of a long list of reasons not to watch this. Honestly if everything was kept the same and only Matt was replaced this would still not do well, because the production itself- from the wardrobe, to the editing, the styling, the acting, etc. is not up to par.

What I can agree is that it would not flop this badly if she was not in this. It would probably average around 2 to 3% with its highest rating being 4.5 max for its final episode ( and even that’s being optimistic). But under no circumstances can I see this being a hit- with or without Matt- because there are just so many other issues. Even is she was replaced by Yaya, whose miles aged in popularity and fandom power I’d still think the same would happen.

On that note, not to be rude but I think people are really overestimating Nadech’s rating pull. His last 2 lakorns were also very big, highly promoted productions and they also flopped. They averaged 4.74% and 3.45% respectively which may not seem all that bad but considering their scale- the marketing and hype surrounding both lakorns, the results were lacklustre at best. And they were with Yaya so there is no excuse like koojin fans being turned off. The funny thing is that over the past 5 years his most successful lakorn was NOT with Yaya but with Mew so its literally just an excuse.

Btw I’m not downplaying his popularity or Yaya’s. I’m saying that a big fandom and ratings success aren’t really related. It’s like in kpop how you have some artists with big fandoms who have really big physical sales, win all the awards, can hold large fan meetings/ concerts but then can’t really get on the digital charts. Yaya and Nadech like that.
 

ArabellaRose

sarNie Hatchling
I don’t mean to sound disagreeable by being brutally honest. But although it maybe true that this “remake would still be a flop without Matt, She is the reason why it is a MAJOR flop (1.8/ 1.6 )
As for the rating , I beg to differ, but this would be 3 to 4 rating with all the technical issues and without Matt. Not 2-3. With Matt and without technical issues it might make it to 2-2.6. Thai lakorns with problems like LR did get from 3 to 4 but that’s not a kdrama remake.

Remakes are different from normal lakorns when it comes to viewership. The hype would have made it more popular. So the base rating regardless of technical issues isn’t the same.Also It cannot be assumed that just because an actor or actress did this much in his or her past rating that they will generate the same, especially the rating of a popular kdrama remake. The technical aspects are variables. Again fans would probably endure bad remakesl regardless let say if it’s bad technically just to support their idols. Like many here continue to endure regardless of boredom . So what more of their real fans?. . But again not if they can’t stand the actress . Matt not being there would probably see this remake with a little more decent and respectable rating..
I think there are considerable number of Nadechs and NY fans that if they choose to watch would bump up the ratings.. But 1.8... it means his fans didn’t watch, . it would not go down to 1.6 or 1.8 even with all the technical issues.. Nadech NEVER had 1.6 and 1.8 rating in the past if we start to talk about past rating EVEN WITH Technical issues. ..BUT THE FANS DIDNT WATCH ..Why? They didn’t like Matt? Perhaps the love-scenes? even if they can endure the bad editing etc, They didn’t watch. They didn’t have to watch. They’re just simply not interested ..This 1.8 rating is very telling..There are also considerable number of people in public who could have watch but didn’t. They said they wouldnt and they didn’t and they said it’s becsuse of Matt. 1.8 is a very significant drop. It tells most people who used to watch , didn't.

In terms of casting. I heard this wouldn’t have been made if Nadech wasn’t there. Becsuse the korean ends wants him as lead, So I suppose he should have passed, Nadechs acting is based on his own interpretation. It’s hard to judge a person playing an alien. As for Matt, I think her acting didn’t quite work. She just copied and it’s annoying as hell. I don’t think she really is the right actress for the role. They need someone likable, First, jun ji hyun , appearance wise is extemely charismatic and beautiful. I’m not saying Matt isnt beautiful. She’s just not the same level as JJH. Then she copied her acting. But it didn’t have the same effect, it came off as annoyingly overacting with bold movements instead of adorably annoying. Whatever number of fans she has ( and I don’t think there’s much to begin with) and considering her issues for sure had didn’t watch as well.
 
Last edited:

sasuke06

sarNie Adult
Why people are working so hard trying to determine why this lakorn is a flop? Lol. I mean in Thailand, they don't wonder about such a thing coz the reason is quite evident.

Reasons:
1 - Matt
.
.
∞ Matt

Because at the end, if you want to talk about the rating, who cares if the production, script, editing, wardrobes, location and actors are good or not if people has simply decided to NOT WATCH IT? You can't debute that low with a 1,8 whereas it is supposed to be one of the biggest ch3 project, this is a real boycott. This remake was highly anticipated before Matt's scandal coz it's the 1st time ch3 has decided to remake a Kdrama but it went down after how badly nangek handled her scandals with her wild "Jaaa interview" and her provocative "happy new year post". She provoked thai people, she got the consequence right away on her face but she dragged all these people, actors, production, ch3 who have worked so hard for nothing with her.

There is no hype at all here, everything is low compared to any usual lakorn, even lower than D list actors with D list productions :nut: The rating, the views, the tweets after ep1....LOW! Debuted with 1,8!!! OH MY...:eek: REAL BOYCOTT! Then this K remake is just inferior to the Kdrama. Remake are made to surpass the original version, not the case here. How Matt dared to say once that the thai version was better? Rating that dropped from 1,8 to 1,6 x3eps is the consequence that people lost interest. But I would say WHO CARES if the initial rating 1,8 was already so low!

After ep1, results are: trended No.1 worldwide, in Thailand & in Philippines but the rating... 1,8 HAHAHA. Fake hype? Yes and No, most of the people who brought the hype comes from MLFAS fans, those rare random viewers who decided to give a try and Nadech dedicated fans who have decided to support him no matter what. MLFAS that trended in PH whereas there is no sub...how possible if not thanks to Nadech who has a huge fanbase overthere lol? Even Khun Nong was not delusional and credited this success thanks to Nadech fans (15min30 in the video)



If you say you haven't seen any backlash , you must come from another star for real I mean don't go to official platforms like ch3Thailand to get the feedback. Thai people have decided to boycott MLFAS because of Matt, so they will definitely not click on those links to increase the views, the comments...it makes sense right?! No go elswhere where the backlash is huge, wild,INSANE lol. After the 1st ep, khun Nong said that "the feedback was great, people overall (1,8 as reminder lol) praised the production, actors, CGI but the rating is completely at the opposite, I don't know why"....how to politely and indirectly said "Eee MATT" lol. I really pity khun Nong who have invested so much "I will not watch it ja. I don't like nang ek. The storyline is good, fun but too bad you chose this actress".

1570372564676.png


The backlash here :eek: These are the Top comments.

- They stop watching from the entire district only because of her :risas3:
- They created the hype themself, promote themself but the rating is at the opposite because of the actress
- I hate nang'ek's face (maen kee na lol). As soon as I see her face, I directly dodge her
- I don't watch because I don't like the bad behavior of the actress. She looks like nang rai (mean actress).
- I watch LiKhit Hang Jan, it's fun to look at the actress but this lakorn I just can't. I don't like the actress.
- I hate Matt, I don't watch. Better to watch korean version, more fin.
- I would like to help Nadech and the team production so I barely watched it but I can't IN. I didn't remind her "image" but it came back alone so I gave up. Sorry P'Nong 555
- Matt has a big impact for sure. I tried to differentiate (real life from professional life) but I can't IN. Before I loved her so much. I don't know if her stealing someone's husband is true or not. In real I don't care but her image is RAENG! It has consequences on her role. I have a thought for the team production of this lakorn.




Even some parts of Nadech fans have decided to not watch this lakorn coz they can't stand Matt. Top comments:
jppa__opไม่ดูค่ะ ไม่สนับสนุนการแย้งสามีคนอื่น I don't watch! I don't support an actress who stole someone's else husband
r_o_s_e_8 เกลียดหน้านางเอกคนนี้ ไม่ดูค่ะ I hate this actress's face. I will not watch
meesomthon ไม่ดูไม่ชอบนางเอก I'll not watch, I don't like the actress
mymint_millada เสียดายณเดช จังเลย ผ่านไม่ดูแน่นอน I pity Nadech so much :sad6:But next, I'll not watch for sure
ohohirun21 อยากดูณเดชแต่แม็กไม่ดูดีกว่า I want to watch Nadech but better not
noi_ophasai เสียดาย ณเดช ไม่ดูคะ..เกลียด ผญ.หน้าด้าน It's a waste for Nadech. I will not watch, I hate this sassy cheeky girl.
http://instagr.am/p/B2TInENF6iw/

Top comments:
tubbuntom ไม่มีใครดูหรอกเสียดายพระเอกจัง Nobody will watch it. Such a waste for the praek
sachyukon ขออนุญาตไม่ดูนะคะ รักน้องณเดชค่ะ I ask the permission to not watch it ka but I love Nadech
nittayalyssand เสียดายพระเอกจัง ไม่น่าเลย ไม่น่าคู่กับคนนี้ อยากดูแต่ไม่ดีกว่า☹ What a waste for the praek, it shouldn't have been this way. It doesn't make you envy to watch because of "that person". I want to watch but better not ☹
yldaasmpradii ฉายหนังวันไหนค่ะ จะได้เปลี่ยนช่อง ไปดูช่องอื่น When this lakorn will be on air? So that I will switch over channel
jup_me1 เสียดายพระเอกจัง. ขอรอดูเรื่องอื่นนะคะ Such a waste for the actor, let me watch your next lakorn na ka.
ben_namassiya อยากดูน้องแบร์ แต่นางเอก ดูแล้วไม่อิน น่าจะไม่ได้ดูนะคะ ไว้รอดูเรื่องหน้านะน้องแบร์^^ I want to watch Barry but the actress...seeing her I can't IN. I may not watch it. Let me watch your next lakorn ok Barry!
http://instagr.am/p/B2Vnm-IBrmK/


And it's not only about Nadech fans, MLFAS fans and brodcast, Matt could drag another victim lol. After the No.1 actor in Thailand with the best image, they choose to pair her up with another promising ch3 rising star with a clean image, Nine Naphat! His fans are pissed. Before we got to see some #savePope after his sex scandals have been leaked now you can see some #saveNaphat :risas3: Go read the comments, it's entertaining lol

koyhunjang #savenaphat
jessieboston21 อย่าเลยค่ะ สงสารผู้จัด Don't do this, I pity the producer
ampushka สงสารน้องนาย I pity nong Nine
gambum08 สงสารน้องนายน้องนายน่ารัก I pity nong Nine, he's cute...
rojarek0017 เจ๊ดัน หรือเจ๊ดึงลง Sister who pushes him or sister who pushes him down
natty_prapaporn แมทดันน้องนาย หรือ เอาน้องนายมาเรียกกระแสให้แมทกลับมากันแน่คะ Matt pushes nong Nine or you take Nine to bring buzz for Matt instead?
nureeyah_5 ยังไม่เข็ด เห็นนางเอกล่ะไม่อยากดูเลยจ้าาา ลิขิตรักข้ามดวงดาวอยากดูแต่ไม่อยากเหผ้นหน้านางเอกเพราะฉนั่นไม่ดูดีกว่าเสียอารมณ์ You have still not learnt? I see the actress and I already don't want to watch it jaaa. I wanted to watch MLFAS but I don't want to see her face therefore better to not watch. Lose my temper!
zero_one_6789 คือช่อง 3 กำลังฝ่ากระแสแอนตี้อะ พยามดันๆๆแหลก น่าสงสารพระเอกที่ประกบด้วยจัง เวรกรรม!!!! กี่ศพแล้วนี่ ที่ร่วงไปกับนาง // นางเอกน้ำดีคก็มีเยอะ ไม่เรียกใช้บ่อยๆหน่อยอะ (Bonus lol)
http://instagr.am/p/B20kg3ChbLN/

My point is you should stop wasting your energy to find X Y Z reasons of why this lakorn's is a flop in term of rating because it was already meant to be a failure before it had the opportunity to begin. The evidences of who is the responsible is CRYSTAL CLEAR! "THE MATT EFFECT". She got interviewed recently by the media and they asked her what does she think about people blaming her for these results, she said "I understand and accept it". So people should move on. The rare real watchers who enjoy this lakorn...keep watching it if not, drop it as simple as it is. As for fake watchers who are not interested in praek, nang ek, MLFAS but are so active, you should stop because most of people will react like Sunny by seeing your "TOH FAK TOH FAENG" statements :risas3: What does it mean? Only real MLFAS watchers will get it :naughty2:

 
Last edited:

byebye

sarNie OldFart
Everything about this lakorn is like a headache that's inching closer to a migraine lol. To me, not sure whatever the reason is anymore it just lack appeal. I have watched boring lakorns before or boring dramas and basically tortured myself finishing it but at least the characters aren't annoying. It's insults to injury when the lakorn is boring and the characters are unlikable.

And to the majority of the thai viewers if Janie and some others can thrive after their scandal then taking them seriously after Matt's scandal isn't even an option for me. They act like a scorned lover lol acting like Matt actually steal their boyfriend or husband (it's so personal it's disturbing).

Matt and Nadech has little to no chemistry...what beautiful and effortless chemistry looks like people need to watch My Girlfriend Is An Alien. Now, if Matt and Nadech has that kind of chemistry then there's something to talk about. Instead watching them is like watching fish swimming around in a glass tank lol. The hype for me was real when there's first news about it but after a long delay I didn't care if it aired or not. I got into other stuff and this lakorn became an after thought.

Now tiptoe back to my Turkish series :)
 

ArabellaRose

sarNie Hatchling
Everything about this lakorn is like a headache that's inching closer to a migraine lol. To me, not sure whatever the reason is anymore it just lack appeal. I have watched boring lakorns before or boring dramas and basically tortured myself finishing it but at least the characters aren't annoying. It's insults to injury when the lakorn is boring and the characters are unlikable.

And to the majority of the thai viewers if Janie and some others can thrive after their scandal then taking them seriously after Matt's scandal isn't even an option for me. They act like a scorned lover lol acting like Matt actually steal their boyfriend or husband (it's so personal it's disturbing).

Matt and Nadech has little to no chemistry...what beautiful and effortless chemistry looks like people need to watch My Girlfriend Is An Alien. Now, if Matt and Nadech has that kind of chemistry then there's something to talk about. Instead watching them is like watching fish swimming around in a glass tank lol. The hype for me was real when there's first news about it but after a long delay I didn't care if it aired or not. I got into other stuff and this lakorn became an after thought.

Now tiptoe back to my Turkish series :)
It’s a real shame, they really hyped this drama from the beginning. Really hyped up :risas3:They had to because it’s a big production. So much money was spent. True about the chemistry . I already could somewhat see it from the beginning. But I wasn’t sure because you really have to see the actors acting together to see if the chemistry is there. So I said I’ll wait for the remake to show and judge.. Then... :eek: .. just unbelievable how can one even defend this remake, lol.

As for your headache and migraine..I think this remake is indeed becoming health hazard to others and might even be a cause of mental issues to some,,LoL..enough for people to just go crazy, and come out of nowhere and start attacking and insulting every single people they can. I call It the MLFTS Viewers syndrome....Hahaha:risas3: ..I think I really should not watch anymore....before I end up like that.. :risas3:heck it maybe too late for that..
 

byebye

sarNie OldFart
There's a kiss in episode 7 not sure if there's one in episode 6 cause didn't watch it. I didn't watch the whole episode 7 just the Fin scene of the kiss scene. Seriously, when Na kissed Matt and she has her eyes opened all I thought about was all the K dramas and C dramas I've watched where the FL opened their eyes while being kissed hahahah.

Yeah, them as a couple is a complete dud lol. I was waiting for a kiss to see at least if there's something there. But nope, nothing. Basically two people kissing that doesn't generate an ounce of spark. Sigh....I might check some Fin scenes here and there other than that this lakorn is off to the background for good.
 

allicho

sarNie Oldmaid
Still waiting for the hype regarding this Korean remake drama of why the drama was good and entertaining because the storyline is boring.

After Mina's death ( what a wasted role for Yogurt and unbeknownst to me, a murder plot too o_O), I didn't like where the plot was heading but kept on with it. I am still trying to watch til the end (episode 16?), but am at episode 4 and I've snoozed twice while watching it. Majority of the scenes were in Achira's condo, I felt suffocated and needed air from that studio set. I am not alone, when I say it's a disappointment and I am directing that to the BORING storyline. In addition, I don't care for the editing, style, and the melodramatic characters (Falada included, her mom, managers, reporters, etc.). There's no chemistry between the leads in the 4 episodes I've watched. I cringed and omg at some of the real life parodies. So far the only enjoyable scenes are the Specials after the episodes, though I managed to see a clip of drunked Achira for episdoe 6 :risas3:.

For me, this is not a must see right now, but a wait and see when it finished airing so I can FF the supporting characters and find out the ending.
 

bit

sarNie Adult
If this were some Spanish or Hollywood series, they will throw the leads out after seeing the lacklustre chemistry during screen test.
 

ArabellaRose

sarNie Hatchling

ArabellaRose

sarNie Hatchling
I can’t help but feel somwhat concern for Nadech. :confused12:If they copy all of them. Especially The red carpet Kiss . I Hope it doesn’t become controversial. Cause this remake is so not worth it for his career. Perhaps he got paid a lot. But all things considered with the scandal and quality of this remake.. I just think he wasted a full 1 year shooting this. Then for the first time kissing someone other than yaya and not just one kiss but many real kisses. The korean version wasn’t shy when it comes to kisses. I don’t think Koreans do any fake one.lol. When I heard they want to film it a certain way. I thought Nadech is going to have to do some real serious kissing.. and more than he ever had in any of his lakorns as this drama is known for many iconic kisses.:risas3:. I know he has many real fans. But I’m sure there are also who would be those disappointed, Of all the actresses he has to kiss. It could have been mew or Kim or taew. But, It’s someone involved in scandal whom many people don’t like ..lol.. I wonder what the reaction of those people would be to Nadech kissing Matt. LOL. Right away bcsuse the remake went up by .2 there already many people promoting the kisses :risas3: Like for coming episodes that can be what they show as a preview.lol..I think there are that many kisses if I’m not mistake from the original.... LoL..This might end up to be known as one of those who become popular bcsuse of skinship instead of The quality of remake , the story and the acting,.. it would not be good for the actors,:facepalm:
 
Last edited:

spanky

sarNie OldFart
Ananda...adapt/remake k series and make it his own at least....

He add more sweet scenes and make them less rigid
 

byebye

sarNie OldFart
I can’t help but feel somwhat concern for Nadech. :confused12:If they copy all of them. Especially The red carpet Kiss . I Hope it doesn’t become controversial. Cause this remake is so not worth it for his career. Perhaps he got paid a lot. But all things considered with the scandal and quality of this remake.. I just think he wasted a full 1 year shooting this. Then for the first time kissing someone other than yaya and not just one kiss but many real kisses. The korean version wasn’t shy when it comes to kisses. I don’t think Koreans do any fake one.lol. When I heard they want to film it a certain way. I thought Nadech is going to have to do some real serious kissing.. and more than he ever had in any of his lakorns as this drama is known for many iconic kisses.:risas3:. I know he has many real fans. But I’m sure there are also who would be those disappointed, Of all the actresses he has to kiss. It could have been mew or Kim or taew. But, It’s someone involved in scandal whom many people don’t like ..lol.. I wonder what the reaction of those people would be to Nadech kissing Matt. LOL. Right away bcsuse the remake went up by .2 there already many people promoting the kisses :risas3: Like for coming episodes that can be what they show as a preview.lol..I think there are that many kisses if I’m not mistake from the original.... LoL..This might end up to be known as one of those who become popular bcsuse of skinship instead of The quality of remake , the story and the acting,.. it would not be good for the actors,:facepalm:
Bless their little hearts if all they have is being mad or disappointed that an actor is doing his job. That's a cushion life.

Nadech will be fine going forward with or without this remake. I mean, they hand picked him from the beginning. Being an actor sometimes you have to kiss a frog rather than the princess lol. But as a professional they have to put on a happy face and take one for the team hahaha.

And this lakorn isn't going to put a dent on his popularity let alone his career. He's so darn popular he probably got some young girls following his IG even if he turns 80 lol. Now, Matt on the other hand...that's another whole universe of a story :)
 
Top